Make the most delicious homemade doughnuts by following this simple step-by-step tutorial. These doughnuts, also called Spudnuts, are made with mashed potatoes, which make them extra fluffy and yummy.
*This post may contain affiliate links. For more info, check out our Privacy & Disclosure Policy.
Doughnuts aka Spudnuts
Have you ever wanted to make doughnuts, but been to scared to try?
Don’t you worry. Homemade donuts (or spudnuts as we call them since they have potatoes in them) are one of our all-time favorite Halloween traditions.
Making spudnuts does require some time and patience, i.e. it’s a few hour process. But even though it’s a long process, it’s an easy one. Today I’m going to show you step-by-step how to get amazing homemade spudnuts every time.
I’m a 3rd generation doughnut maker and my husband and I host a homemade spudnut party every Fall. We usually triple the batch, meaning we make over 300 spudnuts! We love inviting neighborhood friends and family over for a donut free-for-all. It’s one of our favorite parties of the year! After doing this for 9 years, we’ve learned lots of tips that make the process more streamlined.
So read on if you’d like to learn from the pros. (Although we won’t be quitting our day jobs anytime soon. 🙂
How to Make the Spudnut Dough
*See below for the full, printable recipe. You may want to print off the recipe and then use it side-by-side with these tips.
Make mashed potatoes. While you can use instant potatoes for your spudnuts, we prefer the real deal. Make them a day in advance to cut down on prep time. Be sure you mix/mash them very well so they are smooth, not lumpy. Add in a little milk to get this consistency. Be sure not to add butter, or salt and pepper.
Tip: Make the mashed potatoes a day in advance. They do not need to be warm to use in the recipe.
Scald the milk. You’ll know it’s scalded when there is a thin film on the top of the milk. It usually happens right before it boils. Then remove the milk from heat and let it cool. You’ll still want it slightly warm to help activate the yeast. But it should not be hot to the touch.
While the milk is cooling (you can put it in the fridge to speed up the process), mix the yeast, sugar, and water together and let sit for about 5 minutes until frothy.
Slightly beat the eggs and set aside. Cream sugar and shortening together in a new bowl. Add in the eggs and potatoes and mix well. Then add yeast mixture and cooled milk. Slowly add in flour and salt. (You will probably add in an extra 2 cups of flour so that it isn’t sticky.)
The dough will get very heavy and thick. You can use a Kitchenaid or Bosch for this process, but once you add in about 8-10 cups, it’s usually best to finish mixing by hand to avoid burning out the motors of your machine.
Once the dough is mixed well and smooth, let rise in a large bowl with a clean towel over the top. Let rise for at least 1 1/2 hours, but up to 3-4 hours is fine.
*Now for the fun part: rolling out, cooking, and glazing:
1. Generously flour a clean surface. Roll out the dough about 1/2 inch thick.
2. Use a donut cutter or a sturdy cup and bottle lid to cut donut shapes and holes out of the dough.
3. Once they have been cut, move them to trays covered with wax paper. The wax paper is optional, but sure cuts down on clean-up time! You will need lots of trays. This year, we splurged and bought 10 extra trays from the dollar store. They worked great and held a dozen each.
4. Let the spudnuts rise another half hour at least. Although, honestly, they can rise a few hours again and be fine. While they are rising the 2nd time, we like to start cleaning up some of the mess and get ready for the party.
5. Once you are ready to fry, fill up a donut fryer or our favorite, an electric fry pan with 1/2 inch oil. It needs to be deep enough so that both sides of the spudnut get cooked when flipped. If you use an electric fry pan, it will keep the heat even and you can fry about 8-9 at a time.
6. Cook the spudnuts until golden brown and then flip. Once both sides have been cooked, move them to a pan lined with paper towels. Let the grease drain for a minute or so. You will probably go through lots of paper towels during the process.
7. While the spudnuts are still warm, dip them in homemade glaze (recipe above). My sister taught us the best trick. Use chopsticks for this process. Slide the chopstick through the hole and then you can glaze a few at a time.
8. Let the glaze drip off a little bit before you move them to serving platters.
9. Repeat the process until have been fried and glazed. Each batch makes 100-120. Enjoy the journey. Grab someone to help you and it will be a lot more fun.
See, I told you it was a big process, but to hear how much EVERYONE loves these spudnuts makes it all worth it.
Okay, so you’re ready to try making doughnuts, donuts, or spudnuts? Whatever you want to call them, here’s the recipe for melt in your mouth goodness… Enjoy!